Is it better to raise cats or dogs? For beginners who want to take their first step into pet ownership, this is indeed a puzzling question. Simply put, if you pursue relatively independent pets that don't require much outdoor activity and can accept their "aloof" companionship, then cats might suit you better; whereas if you crave enthusiastic interaction, are willing to invest a lot of time and effort in training and companionship, and enjoy the fun of outdoor activities, then dogs may be your best choice. Understanding the differences between cats and dogs, combined with your own lifestyle and expectations, helps you find the most suitable "fur baby."

Is it better to raise cats or dogs? This is truly a "century dilemma," just like how people in the south prefer rice and those in the north favor noodles—there is no absolute answer; it entirely depends on your personal situation and preferences. Both have their charms, and "cat lovers" and "dog lovers" have their own reasons. In China, more and more people are raising pets, especially in big cities, and the "pet economy" is booming accordingly. Cats and dogs, as the most popular pets, naturally become the focus of public attention. According to some data, the number of pet cats and dogs in Chinese urban areas has reached hundreds of millions, with annual spending on pets reaching into the hundreds of billions. People born in the '80s and '90s are the main forces behind pet ownership, and women dominate pet-related consumption.

Cats: Independent and Free-Spirited "Pooper Scooper" Companions

The experience of raising cats is sometimes humorously called like dating; sometimes they are passionate and clingy, other times "indifferent," playing by themselves with strong personalities. Cats are usually quite independent and don’t require the owner’s constant companionship. Even if you are very busy with work or often on business trips, as long as you prepare enough cat food, water, and a clean litter box, cats can mostly stay at home by themselves and won’t experience the separation anxiety dogs often have. This is undoubtedly a great advantage for young urbanites with fast-paced lives and limited living spaces.

Advantages of raising cats:

• Highly independent, requiring relatively little companionship: Cats spend most of their time sleeping or playing alone, suitable for busy office workers or those working "996" schedules.
• Easy to train for elimination: Cats naturally use litter boxes and usually need only simple guidance once. This greatly reduces the owner’s burden, unlike dogs that require daily outdoor walks to address these needs.
• Require little space, suitable for apartment living: Cats don’t need large activity spaces like large dogs. A small apartment or single dorm room can comfortably accommodate them.
• Quiet: Compared to dogs’ barking, cats are usually quiet and less likely to disturb neighbors, especially suitable for apartment residents.
• Clean: Cats spend a lot of time grooming themselves to maintain cleanliness.
• Relatively low exercise needs: Cats’ exercise mainly comes from playing and daily home activity, without the need for long daily walks like dogs.

Points to note when raising cats:

• Relatively independent personality, different interaction styles: Some cats are not as affectionate as dogs; their way of expressing love can be "aloof," needing time for you to understand and build trust.
• Training can be more difficult: Compared to dogs’ "obedience," cats care more about "whether I feel like it," so training requires more patience and methods.
• May scratch furniture: Cats have a natural need to scratch. Without guidance or sufficient scratching posts, furniture may be damaged. Providing various scratching surfaces and toys can reduce this.
• Sensitive to environmental changes: Cats have a strong territorial sense, and moving or changing home layout can stress them.
• Medical costs may be higher: Although cats may not get sick as frequently as dogs, treatments for illness, especially complex conditions, can be expensive.

Cat breeds suitable for beginners:

• Chinese Rural Cat: Strong adaptability, good health, intelligent and lively, relatively low-maintenance.
• British Shorthair: Gentle, quiet, good health, suitable for home life.
• American Shorthair: Gentle, healthy, strong adaptability, relatively active, requires some play space.
• Ragdoll: Gentle and clingy, friendly to people, highly tolerant, good looking, suitable for families with time to accompany.

Dogs: Enthusiastic "Shadow" Companions

Raising dogs is more like raising a “little child.” They wholeheartedly devote enthusiasm to you and need a lot of love and companionship. Dogs are usually lively and active, like to interact with their owners, and crave attention and petting. If you enjoy outdoor sports and the fun of running and playing with a pet, dogs will be a great partner. They are loyal to their owners and your most reliable "little follower."

Advantages of raising dogs:

• Strong enthusiastic interaction: Dogs are usually very enthusiastic with their owners, like to interact and play, bringing more joy and energy to life.
• Easy to train: Dogs’ "obedient nature" makes them easier to train, able to learn commands and behavior rules.
• Provides more social opportunities: Walking dogs gives chances to meet other dog owners and expand social circles. As some dog owners say, "It’s less about walking the dog socially and more about finding friends I can chat with."
• Promotes exercise: Regular daily dog walking increases outdoor activity time and benefits health.
• Loyal and reliable companion: Dogs are very loyal to their owners and your most trusted partners.

Points to note when raising dogs:

• Requires a lot of time and effort: Dogs need daily walks, companionship, and training, especially as puppies, requiring more time and patience for guidance. Some feel raising a dog is like raising a young child.
• High exercise needs: Most dogs require ample exercise to burn energy, or they may engage in destructive behaviors like tearing up the house.
• Needs patience for elimination training: Dog elimination training usually requires repeated guidance over time, unlike cats that instinctively use litter boxes.
• May bark and affect neighbor relations: Some dogs are prone to barking, which, if not properly trained, may disturb neighbors.
• Requires relatively large space: Especially medium to large dogs need bigger living and activity areas.
• Relatively high maintenance costs: Expenses on food, toys, training, and medical care usually exceed those of cats. According to Chinese data, the average annual cost per pet dog is generally higher than cats.

Dog breeds suitable for beginners:

For beginner-friendly dogs, generally consider breeds with gentle temperaments, easy training, moderate or small size, and relatively lower exercise demands.

• Labrador Retriever: Gentle and friendly, easy to train, adaptable, suitable for families.
• Golden Retriever: Mild, friendly temperament, high intelligence, easy training, good looking—known as the "people’s dog."
• Bichon Frise: Small size, gentle temperament, requires grooming, low exercise needs.
• Toy Poodle: Intelligent, non-shedding, minimal odor, needs regular grooming.
• Corgi: Lively and friendly, small and cute size, but watch over spinal health.
• Pug: Calm personality, enjoys quiet companionship, suitable for apartment living.
• French Bulldog: Small size, gentle temperament, suitable for smaller living spaces.

Choosing Cats or Dogs Ultimately Depends on "Fate" and "Personality Match"

As the saying goes, "birds of a feather flock together." Sometimes, pet ownership also depends on "chemistry" and "personality compatibility." Studies show that "cat lovers" tend to be more introverted, open, sensitive, and lenient on details; while "dog fans" are more lively, extroverted, and more likely to follow rules. Of course, this is only a general trend; specific personality traits of cats or dogs vary based on individual differences, upbringing environment, and owner’s care methods.

The choice between cat and dog is more about examining your lifestyle, living environment, available time and energy, and financial ability.

• Living environment: If you live in a space-limited apartment or find it difficult to frequently go out, cats might be more suitable. If you have a yard or the convenience to take dogs out often, then conditions favor raising dogs.
• Work and social life: If your work is busy, with frequent overtime or travel, and you have little time to accompany pets, independent cats may fit your pace better. If you have free time, enjoy socializing and outdoor activities, dogs will bring you more fun.
• Family members: If you have children or elderly family members, choose gentle and people-friendly breeds. Some dogs (such as Labradors and Goldens) and cats (such as Ragdolls) perform well in this regard. Also consider how new pets will get along with existing ones, requiring patience and adaptation.
• Budget: Pet ownership entails significant expenses, including food, medical care, supplies, grooming, and training. Dogs usually cost more overall, especially large breeds or those needing special care. Beginners should budget in advance to ensure adequate finances for good pet care.
• Personality and expectations: Do you prefer quiet companionship or crave lively interaction? Do you enjoy the relaxed "cat stroking" or like running around with a dog? Clarifying your expectations helps make choices that match your heart.

Tips for Beginner Pet Owners

Whether you choose a cat or a dog, pet ownership is a serious responsibility requiring time, effort, patience, and money. They are not toys but living beings who need your care for life.

• Do your homework in advance: Learn about different breeds’ habits, pros and cons, and potential problems.
• Prepare necessary supplies: Dog food/cat food, bowls, water dishes, leash/litter box, toys, beds, etc.
• Find a reliable source: Purchase or adopt pets through formal channels to avoid "puppy mills" or "kitten mills."
• Get early health checks and vaccinations: Take pets to veterinary hospitals for exams and follow medical advice for vaccinations and deworming.
• Be patient with training and socialization: Especially for dogs, conduct basic and socialization training to help adaptation to human society. Cats also require guidance for tasks like litter use and scratching posts.
• Provide enough love and companionship: No matter how busy, make time to spend with your "fur baby," interact and play to build a deep bond.
• Pay attention to your pet’s health: Monitor their diet, elimination, and mental state; seek timely medical care if abnormalities arise.

In summary, raising cats or dogs is not about absolute "easy" or "hard," but about "suitable" or "unsuitable." We hope this guide helps you comprehensively understand the differences between cats and dogs and make a wise choice tailored to your situation to welcome your special "fur baby" and start a journey full of love and responsibility!

Frequently Asked Questions

• Which cat breeds are suitable for beginners?
  Cat breeds suitable for beginners generally have gentle personalities, strong adaptability, and are easy to care for, such as Chinese Rural Cats, British Shorthairs, American Shorthairs, and Ragdolls.
• Which dog breeds are suitable for beginners?
  There are many dog breeds suitable for beginner owners, including Labradors, Golden Retrievers, Bichons, Toy Poodles, Corgis, Pugs, and French Bulldogs. They usually have gentle temperaments and are easy to train.
• Which costs more, raising a cat or a dog?
  Generally, raising a dog costs more overall, especially in food, toys, training, and medical care.
• Which requires more time companionship, cats or dogs?
  Dogs usually need more time and energy from owners, with daily walks and interaction. Cats are more independent and can stay home longer alone.
• Can cats and dogs live together?
  Cats and dogs can live together but need breeds that are relatively gentle and friendly, along with patient guidance and adaptation.

References:

Cats vs. Dogs: Which Is the Best Pet for Me? (2016-12-09)
10 Cat Breeds Suitable for Beginners - Cats - What’s Worth Buying (2024-06-06)
Top 10 Beginner-Friendly Dogs, Besides Labradors and Goldens - NetEase (2024-01-10)
Is it better to have a cat or a dog if you live in an apartment? - Quora (2022-11-23)
Complete Guide to Dog Breeds: Top 10 Friendly Breeds for Beginners - Smelly Cat Zoo (2025-01-24)
Beginner Cat Care - Entry Guide on Best Breeds, Basics, Preparations, and Checklist - CSDN Blog (2022-04-24)
Differences Between Raising Cats and Dogs—Here Are the Answers - Sina (2019-11-27)
[HELP] First Time Pet Owner in an Apartment, Dog vs Cat and What Breed? - Reddit (2024-11-10)
Which Cat Breeds Are Easy for Beginners? - Pets (2025-01-21)
Don’t Know How to Choose a Dog? Top 10 Best Dogs for Beginners Recommended by Experienced Dog Lovers! - Sina (2018-12-23)
10 Best Dog Breeds for Beginners - PetBacker (2023-01-03)
Suitable Cat Breeds for Beginners, High Appearance, Good Temperament, Unforgettable at First Sight | Cat Raising - NetEase (2020-04-23)
Must-Read for New Cat Owners: How to Choose Cats Suitable for Families and Important Considerations - Smelly Cat Zoo (2025-01-24)
How to Choose the Right Dog Breed for You - Pets (2025-03-03)
The Pros And Cons Of Owning A Cat Vs A Dog (2024-06-01)
Pet Humanization in China: How Dogs and Cats Are Becoming an Integral Part of Chinese Society and Economy - Acuity Knowledge Partners (2023-07-10)
What Are the Pros and Cons of Having a Dog or Cat as a Pet in an Apartment? - Quora (2023-03-06)
Raising Cats or Dogs: Do You Know These Differences? - Sina (2019-04-14)
Is Raising Dogs Too Costly? Cats Take Top Spot in Japan Pet Rankings - Xinhua (2017-12-27)
How Much Do Pets Cost in Time and Money (2024-03-19)
How Cats Have Replaced Dogs as China’s Top Pets (2024-03-29)
Cat House (Pet Guide) - Differences Between Cats and Dogs Are So Real It’s Said That Raising... - Tencent Channel (2024)
Are German Shepherds Good with Kittens? What Beginners Need to Know Before Raising Cats or Dogs - Zhihu (2024-08-26)
"Fur Baby" Economy: Cute Pet Craze Hits, by Cai Minzi, Exchange Magazine Issue 164 (Historical Data)
High Energy Ahead: 15 Hilarious Situations Show Differences Between Cats and Dogs - Furkids (2022-03-14)
US Top Pet Food Exporter to China’s $22 Billion Market in 2024 - Petfood Industry (2025-04-09)
Cat Economy Is Rising | EqualOcean (2022-08-30)
Core Seven Questions on Pet Economy: Space? Innovation? 618 Sale Results? (2024-06-17)
Want to Raise a Cat or Dog? So Conflicted...: r/dogs - Reddit (2022-04-25)
Differences Between Raising Cats and Dogs? - Weibo (2019-12-30)
Dog People vs. Cat People: Who's More Outgoing? More Intelligent? - Live Science (2014-05-27)
Aging Population and Rising "Pet Fever" in East Asia - China Foreign Trade Enterprise Service Network (2024-07-31)
What Are the Biggest Differences Between Raising a Dog and a Cat? : r/puppy101 - Reddit (2022-10-04)
Does Raising Dogs Cost More Than Cats in Japan? - Nikkei Chinese Website (2018-08-08)
Are You Ready to Be a Pet Parent? Important Notes Before Welcoming a Fur Baby
Dogs Vs. Cats: Which One Is Better? - Smoky Now (2023-01-29)
Undercover Investigations Expose Cruelty: China's Cat and Dog Meat Trade
Have a Cat But Want a Dog, Too? Here's How to Make It Work - Kinship (2024-01-19)
Raising Pets? First See What Personality the Baby Has - Parenting - Sina (2013-05-17)
Is There a "Right Time" to Raise a Puppy? : r/puppy101 - Reddit (2023-02-07)
Product Trends Under the Pet Economy Wave! - Industry News (2019-05-29)
Dog Breeds That Can Coexist Peacefully With Cats - Pets (2024-12-08)
Which Cats Are Suitable for Beginners and What to Consider When Raising Cats—Includes Pet Supplies Sharing - What’s Worth Buying (2020-05-05)
Cloud Cat Raising: New Life of "Empty Nest Youth" in First-Tier Cities - China Youth Daily - CYOL
The "Value" of a Pet Is Reshaping the Consumer Market - Xinhua (2025-03-26)
[Beginner Cat Owner Guide] See the 3 Major Precautions Before Raising a Cat (2023.04)
7000 Words Explaining | How Pet Brands Use Strategies on Xiaohongshu - Tencent News (2022-11-17)
Cloud Cat Raising: New Life of "Empty Nest Youth" in First-Tier Cities—Public Welfare—People's Daily Online